at first it seemed like it would be a bunch of attempts at anime OP/ED music, as if this is only a vehicle or showcase for a soundtrack composer, but once the choral vocals start it becomes a lot more dramatic, "real" and has a more "full" feeling to it. it's still definitely in the anime soundtrack realm, but it reminds me of a mix of older, more acclaimed and "artistic" soundtrack compsers. kenji kawai, masumi ito and geinoh yamashirogumi were the 3 names that specifically came to mind. there's probably a lot of conscious influence from at least 2 of those
there's strange switches between very clean and complex sounding production like on tracks 1 & 3, and very amateur sounding recording like 2 & 4. the songwriting on 2 & 4 also feel more shoehorned and like if someone working at a TV studio was told "hey go write something orchestral real quick"
the sea shanty one was gay
i liked the last track the most but i also think it's stylistically and thematically completely out of place. reminded me of the more mellow moments of indie j-pop groups like passepied and school food punishment
it was decent overall, but it still has this lingering feeling overall like this is just practice, or a showcase like i mentioned before. sort of like purposefully watching an advertisement instead of a tv show